The Black Box Problem
For three years, we paid an agency $8,000 per month. That's $288,000 over the relationship.
What did we get? Monthly reports we didn't understand. Meetings where they told us things were "going well." Vague explanations when we asked why metrics were down.
We had no idea what they actually did with our money.
The Breaking Point
The moment of clarity came during a quarterly review. We asked a simple question: "How many hours did your team spend on our account last month?"
The answer: "We don't track hours. We focus on results."
But the results weren't there either. Traffic was flat. Leads were down. And we had no visibility into why.
That night, I made the decision to fire them.
Taking Marketing In-House (Sort Of)
The problem with firing your agency: someone still needs to do the work.
We didn't want to hire a full marketing team. We'd been down that road before—the hiring, training, turnover, and management overhead.
That's when we discovered AI could fill the gap.
What AI Replaced
Here's what our $8K/month agency supposedly handled:
| Service | Agency Claim | What AI Does |
|---|---|---|
| SEO | "Ongoing optimization" | Full audits, keyword tracking, content optimization |
| Content | "2 blog posts/month" | 8 posts/month, plus social |
| Social | "Community management" | Daily posting, engagement monitoring |
| Ads | "Campaign management" | Automated bidding, creative testing |
| Reporting | "Monthly review" | Real-time dashboards, AI insights |
The AI does more, shows us everything, and costs a fraction.
The Transparency Difference
With our agency, we saw:
- Monthly reports (delivered 2 weeks after month end)
- High-level metrics only
- No insight into actual work performed
- Excuses when things went wrong
With AI, we see:
- Real-time dashboards
- Every action logged and explained
- Every decision documented
- Clear cause-and-effect analysis
We went from trusting blindly to trusting with verification.
The Results: 6 Months Post-Agency
| Metric | With Agency | With AI (6mo later) |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost | $8,000 | $299 |
| Organic traffic | 12,000 | 34,000 |
| Leads | 45/month | 128/month |
| Cost per lead | $178 | $2.34 |
Read that last line again. Our cost per lead dropped by 98%.
What We Miss About Agencies (Nothing)
I thought I'd miss having people to call. Strategic partners to bounce ideas off. Experts who knew more than us.
Here's what I actually found:
- AI provides better strategic recommendations (based on data, not intuition)
- AI explains its reasoning (try getting an agency to do that)
- AI doesn't take vacations, get sick, or leave for a competitor
The "human touch" of agencies was mostly just overhead.
When Agencies Still Make Sense
To be fair, there are scenarios where agencies add value:
- True creative work: Brand identity, video production, design
- Crisis management: Situations requiring human judgment
- Enterprise scale: When you need bodies in seats for meetings
But for execution-level marketing work? AI wins every time.
Making the Switch
If you're considering firing your agency, here's the playbook:
- Audit current performance — Get actual data, not agency-filtered reports
- Document all services — What are you actually paying for?
- Pilot AI alternatives — Run parallel for one month
- Compare honestly — Same metrics, same time period
- Make the call — The numbers usually make it obvious
Most agencies survive on inertia—clients stay because switching seems hard. Once you see the alternative, you'll wonder why you waited.
Ready to see what your agency is really doing? Get a free audit of your current marketing performance.
